Which Corporate Entity Is Right For Me? - Form an LLC or Corporation Online
Which Entity is Right for me?
There are 2 main entities used in conducting business and protecting assets, corporations and limited liability companies.
InCorp will not tell you which entity to use, but we’d like to educate you so you can choose yourself.
There are a few advantages and disadvantages to corporations and limited liability companies (LLCs).
Let’s outline them here:
This is the most common corporate structure. The corporation is a separate legal entity that is owned by stockholders.
A general corporation may have an unlimited number of stockholders that, due to the separate legal nature of the
corporation, are protected from the creditors of the business. A stockholder's personal liability is usually limited to
the amount of investment in the corporation and no more.
Owners' personal assets are protected from business debt and liability
Corporations have unlimited life extending beyond the illness or death of the owners
Tax free benefits such as insurance, travel, and retirement plan deductions
Transfer of ownership facilitated by sale of stock
Change of ownership need not affect management
Easier to raise capital through sale of stocks and bonds
More expensive to form than proprietorship or partnerships
More legal formality
More state and federal rules and regulations
Double taxation and capital gains tax issues
There are a few minor, but significant, differences between general corporations and close corporations.
In most states where they are recognized, close corporations are limited to 30 to 50 stockholders. In addition,
many close corporation statutes require that the directors of a close corporation must first offer the shares to
existing stockholders before selling to new shareholders.
This type of corporation is particularly well suited for a group of individuals who will own the corporation with some
members actively involved in the management and other members only involved on a limited or indirect level.
With the Tax Reform Act of 1986, the S Corporation became a highly desirable entity for corporate tax purposes.
An S Corporation is not really a different type of corporation. It is a special tax designation applied for and granted
by the IRS to corporations that have already been formed. The S election must be filed 75 days after formation, or within
the first 3 months of your fiscal year. Many entrepreneurs and small business owners are partial to the S Corporation
because it combines many of the advantages of a sole proprietorship, partnership and the corporate forms of business
S Corporations have the same basic advantages and disadvantages of general or close corporation with the added benefit
of the S Corporation special tax provisions. When a standard corporation (general, close or professional) makes a profit,
it pays a federal corporate income tax on the profit. If the company declares a dividend, the shareholders must report
the dividend as personal income and pay more taxes.
S Corporations avoid this "double taxation" (once at the corporate level and again at the personal level) because all
income or loss is reported only once on the personal tax returns of the shareholders. However, like standard corporations
(and unlike some partnerships), the S Corporation shareholders are exempt from personal liability for business debt.
To elect S Corporation status, your corporation must meet specific guidelines. As a result of the 1996 Tax Law, which
became effective January 1, 1997, many of these qualifying guidelines have been changed. A few of these changes are noted
Prior to the 1996 Tax Law, the maximum number of shareholders was 35. The maximum number of shareholders for an S
Corporation has been increased to 75.
Previously, S Corporation ownership was limited to individuals, estates, and certain trusts. Under the new law, stock of
an S Corporation may be held by a new "electing small business trust." All beneficiaries of the trust must be individuals
or estates, except that charitable organizations may hold limited interests. Interests in the trust must be acquired by
gift or bequest -- not by purchase. Each potential current beneficiary of the trust is counted towards the 75 shareholder
limit on S Corporation shareholders.
S Corporations are now allowed to own 80 percent or more of the stock of a regular C corporation, which may elect to file
a consolidated return with other affiliated regular C corporations. The S Corporation itself may not join in that election.
In addition, an S Corporation is now allowed to own a "qualified subchapter S subsidiary." The parent S Corporation must
own 100 percent of the stock of the subsidiary.
Qualified retirement plans or Section 501(c)(3) charitable organizations may now be shareholders in S Corporations.
All S Corporations must have shareholders who are citizens or residents of the United States. Nonresident aliens cannot
S Corporations may only issue one class of stock.
No more than 25 percent of the gross corporate income may be derived from passive income.
An S Corporation can generally provide employee benefits and deferred compensation plans.
S Corporations eliminate the problems faced by standard corporations whose shareholder-employees might be subject to
IRS claims of excessive compensation.
Not all domestic general business corporations are eligible for S Corporation status. These exclusions include:
A financial institution that is a bank;
An insurance company taxed under Subchapter L;
A Domestic International Sales Corporation (DISC); or
Certain affiliated groups of corporations.
Keep in mind, these lists of qualifying S Corporation aspects are not all-inclusive. In addition, there are specific
circumstances in which an S Corporation may owe income tax. For more detailed information about these changes and other
aspects regarding S Corporation status, contact your accountant, attorney or local IRS office.
To become an S Corporation, you must know the mechanics of filing for this special tax status. Your first step is to form
a general, close or professional corporation in the state of your choice. Second, you must obtain the formal consent of
the corporation's shareholders. This consent should be noted in the corporation's minutes. Once the filing is approved,
your company must complete Form 2553, Election by a Small Business Corporation. This form must be filed with the
appropriate IRS office for your region within 75 days of formation, or if making the election later in the corporation’s
existence, must be within the first 3 months of your fiscal year. Please consult the IRS' instructions for Form 2553 to
determine your proper deadline for completing and submitting this form.
LLC’s have long been a traditional form of business structure in Europe and Latin America. LLC’s were first introduced in
the United States by the state of Wyoming in 1977 and authorized for pass-through taxation (similar to partnerships and S
Corporations) by the IRS in 1988. With the recent inclusion of Hawaii, all 50 states and Washington, D.C. have now adopted
some form of LLC legislation for both domestic and foreign (out of state) limited liability companies.
Many business professionals believe LLC’s present a superior alternative to corporations and partnerships because LLC’s
combine many of the advantages of both. With an LLC, the owners can have the corporate liability protection for their
personal assets from business debt as well as the tax advantages of partnerships or S Corporations. It is similar to an S
Corporation without the IRS' restrictions.
Protection of personal assets from business debt
Profits/losses pass through to personal income tax returns of the owners
Great flexibility in management and organization of the business
LLC’s do not have the ownership restrictions of S Corporations making them ideal business structures for foreign investors
Profits of an LLC do not need to be distributed according to percentage of ownership. Example: 4 owners with 25%
ownership each but only 2 of the owners are actually working the business. The Operating Agreement can be written so that
the 2 working owners receive 80% of the profits while only owning 50% of the business.
LLC’s often have a limited life (not to exceed 30 years in many states). Some states require at least 2 members to
form an LLC (not Nevada), and LLC’s are not corporations and therefore do not have stock -- and the benefits of stock
ownership and sales.
Ownership is not as easily transferable
C-Corporations have many tax write off's that an LLC does not. One example of this is the Medical Reimbursement
Plan that a C-Corporation can utilize while LLC members are not allowed to. This can result in very significant tax
LLC’s are treated differently in each state – until there is more established case law, some people fear how the
courts will decide in certain matters of rules and governance.
As with the S Corporation listing, these lists are not inclusive. For more detailed information, please be sure to
speak with a qualified legal and/or financial advisor.
Note that all business entity types generally require a registered agent to receive service of process in almost any jurisdiction
you select. InCorp can provide this registered agent service in all 50 states as well as DC. Call us at (800) 2-INCORP for a quote