LLC vs. S-Corp: Ready to Choose the Best Tax Structure?

Did you know that a simple tax election could potentially save your business thousands of dollars annually without having to change your company's legal structure? Many business owners don't realize they're overpaying self-employment taxes simply because they are't aware of the key differences between LLC and S-Corp tax treatment.

The truth is, your business structure choice isn't just about liability protection anymore. It's about optimizing your tax strategy to keep more money in your pocket while building long-term wealth. But here's the catch: S-Corp elections aren't automatically better for every business situation. Here, we will dive into how LLCs and S-Corps stack up against each other tax-wise so you can determine which option makes the most sense for your specific circumstances.

Key Takeaways

• Understanding tax implications can transform your bottom line: The choice between LLC and S-Corp taxation directly impacts your self-employment tax burden.
• Pass-through taxation benefits both structures: Neither LLCs nor S-Corps face double taxation—profits and losses flow directly to your personal tax return.
• Self-employment tax differences matter: LLCs pay self-employment taxes on all profits, while S-Corp owners only pay these taxes on salary, not distributions.
• Income level determines the best choice: S-Corp elections typically benefit businesses with net profits of $60,000 to $100,000 or more annually, as the tax savings from reduced self-employment taxes start to outweigh the added administrative costs. For businesses with lower profits or those in early stages, the simplicity and flexibility of default LLC taxation often make it the preferable option.
• Expert consultation is worth every penny: The complexity of tax elections and their long-term implications make professional guidance essential for making informed, optimal decisions.

Overview of LLC and S-Corp

Both an LLC and an S-Corp can achieve tax efficiency, but each business structure offers distinct advantages and approaches.

A Limited Liability Company (LLC) is a popular business entity that provides personal asset protection while offering flexibility in management and taxation. LLC owners are referred to as "members" and can include individuals, partnerships, corporations, trusts, and other legal entities. Generally, members' liability is limited to their investment, and they enjoy pass-through tax treatment, similar to that of partnerships. LLCs also offer tax flexibility, allowing them to choose different tax classifications.

An S-Corporation isn't actually a separate business structure—it's a tax election, known as an S election, under Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code that determines how your business profits are taxed for federal income tax purposes. The IRS defines S corporations as "corporations that elect to pass corporate income, losses, deductions, and credits through to their shareholders for federal tax purposes." You first form your business entity, then elect S-Corp status with the IRS by filing Form 2553.

The key distinction is that an LLC is a legal entity structure, while an S-Corp is a purely tax classification that any qualifying corporation or LLC can elect. This means you can have an LLC that's taxed as an S-Corp—getting operational flexibility with tax benefits.

Key Tax Differences Between LLC and S-Corp

Understanding the tax treatment differences between these structures is like having a roadmap to federal income tax savings. Let's break down the specific areas where your tax bill gets impacted.

Pass-Through Taxation

Both LLCs and S-Corps offer pass-through taxation for federal income tax purposes—the business itself doesn't pay federal income tax at the entity level. Instead, profits and losses flow through to your personal tax return, similar to sole proprietorships, where sole proprietors pay income tax at their individual rate. However, unlike sole proprietorships, LLCs and S-Corps provide limited liability protection, meaning your personal property is generally shielded from business debts and lawsuits. This separation reduces your personal liability and helps protect your assets while maintaining tax efficiency.

This arrangement also helps you avoid double taxation faced by C-Corporations, where the company pays corporate taxes first, and then individuals pay personal taxes again on distributions. With pass-through entities, LLC members and S-Corp shareholders are only taxed once at their personal income tax rate on their share of profits.

The key difference lies not in whether you get pass-through treatment—both structures offer it—but in how other taxes, such as self-employment and payroll taxes, are calculated and applied to those passed-through profits.

Self-Employment Taxes

This is where significant tax savings occur. Self-employment taxes fund Social Security and Medicare. LLC members are considered self-employed individuals, and their income is subject to self-employment tax.

For LLCs, you pay self-employment taxes on all business profits. Unlike employees who split these costs with their employers, LLC owners pay the full 15.3% self-employment tax rate—which covers both Social Security (12.4%) and Medicare (2.9%) on all business income.

Example: If your LLC generates $100,000 in profit, you'll pay $15,300 in self-employment taxes alone, plus regular income taxes.

S-Corps change this significantly. Instead, you pay yourself a "reasonable salary" subject to payroll taxes, including FICA taxes (15.3%) under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act, then take additional profits as distributions that avoid self-employment taxes.

Using the same $100,000 example:

You pay yourself a $60,000 reasonable salary (subject to $9,180 in payroll taxes) and take $40,000 as distributions (no self-employment tax). Your total employment tax drops from $15,300 to $9,180—saving $6,120 annually.

Employment Taxes and Payroll Requirements

S-Corp tax savings come with payroll complexity. S-Corps must pay owner-employees a "reasonable salary"—similar to what others in comparable positions earn. The IRS scrutinizes this, and setting salaries too low can trigger audits.

According to business attorney Aaron Hall, "The IRS requires business owners who work in an S corporation to pay themselves a reasonable wage. Without this requirement, business owners could pay themselves $1 per year, which is subject to 15% payroll tax, and the remaining profits received by the business owner would be free of payroll tax" (Aaron Hall Law).

This means S-Corp owners must run payroll, pay quarterly employment taxes, and file payroll tax forms. These payroll taxes include FICA taxes, which cover Social Security and Medicare taxes. Only the salary portion is subject to FICA taxes; additional profits can be taken as distributions, which are not subject to these employment taxes and are instead reported as personal income on your tax return.

LLCs face no such requirements. You can take profits whenever you want with no payroll hassles, but you'll pay self-employment taxes on all profits.

For young entrepreneurs just starting out, the simplicity of an LLC often outweighs the potential savings of an S-Corp until profits justify the added complexity.

Qualified Business Income (QBI) Deduction

Both LLCs and S-Corps can benefit from the Qualified Business Income deduction, allowing you to deduct up to 20% of business income on your personal tax return. This deduction from the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act can significantly reduce your effective tax rate.

Corporate Taxation for LLCs Taxed as Corporations

LLCs can elect to be taxed as a C-Corporation (also known as a C-Corp or C-Corps), but this subjects the LLC to double taxation—corporate taxes on profits plus personal taxes on distributions. This standard corporate tax structure is typically associated with larger businesses or public companies, and this business structure election rarely makes sense for most small businesses; however, it might benefit high-profit companies that retain earnings for growth.

S-Corps never face double taxation since they're designed as pass-through entities.

Flexibility in Profit Distribution

LLCs offer flexibility in how profits are distributed among owners. Each LLC member can receive distributions as determined by the operating agreement, and LLC members are not required to split profits strictly according to ownership percentages. In a multi-member LLC, profit allocations can be specified in the operating agreement, allowing, for example, a 50/50 ownership LLC to allocate 70% of the profits to one member and 30% to the other.

This flexibility makes LLCs attractive for businesses where partners contribute different levels of effort, expertise, or resources, allowing profit sharing to reflect actual contributions rather than just ownership percentages.

S-Corps are rigid—profit distributions must be proportional to stock ownership. Each S-Corporation shareholder receives distributions exactly in line with their percentage of stock ownership. If you own 25% of the stock, you get exactly 25% of the distributions.

State-Level Tax Differences

Some states impose additional taxes on LLCs that don't apply to S-Corps. California charges LLCs an annual franchise tax plus gross receipts fees that can reach thousands of dollars annually. As the U.S. Small Business Administration notes, "Not all states tax S corps equally, but most recognize them the same way the federal government does and tax the shareholders accordingly" (SBA.gov). However, some states don't recognize S-Corp elections at all and tax them as C-Corporations.

Additionally, certain businesses, such as financial institutions, may face restrictions on S-Corp elections, which could impact both state and federal taxes.

Research your state's treatment of both structures before deciding.

Tax Filing Requirements

LLCs and S-Corps follow different filing paths for federal tax purposes that affect complexity and costs.

Single-member LLCs are treated as disregarded entities, typically filing Schedule C with their personal tax returns. Multi-member LLCs file Form 1065 and issue K-1s to members.

S-Corps always file Form 1120S plus issue K-1s to shareholders. The S-Corp return is more complex due to payroll reporting requirements. 

Annual reporting requirements vary by state for both structures, but S-Corps typically face more stringent compliance obligations.

Impact on Owners' Social Security and Medicare Contributions

LLC owners pay self-employment taxes on all business income, which counts toward Social Security earnings history and future benefits.

S-Corp owners only pay Social Security and Medicare taxes on their salary, not distributions. While this saves money now, it might reduce future Social Security benefits.

The trade-off: immediate tax savings versus potentially lower retirement benefits decades later.

Impact of LLC vs. S-Corp on Retirement Plan Contributions

Both structures allow retirement plan contributions, but calculations differ.

S-Corp owner-employees can contribute to retirement plans based on their W-2 salary. LLC owners base contributions on net self-employment income after deducting half of self-employment taxes.

This can sometimes result in higher contribution limits for LLCs, depending on profit levels.

When to Choose an LLC vs. an S-Corp for Tax Purposes

Choosing between these structures isn't about finding the "best" option—it's about finding what works for your specific trade or business situation.

The decision requires careful analysis of your business's unique circumstances.

Considerations for Choosing an LLC for Tax Efficiency

LLCs often make sense when:

• Your business generates modest profits: If you're earning under $60,000-80,000 annually, S-Corp payroll requirements often outweigh potential tax savings.
• You value operational simplicity: LLCs require minimal ongoing formalities—no board meetings or complex payroll requirements.
• You want maximum flexibility: Multiple owners can allocate profits based on their contributions or efforts rather than just ownership percentages.
• You're in the early stages: Building business success often requires flexibility to adapt quickly.
• You have rental income: Rental income and other passive business activities in LLCs are generally not subject to self-employment tax, making LLCs attractive for real estate investors.

Example: Maria runs a consulting business, generating $45,000 in annual revenue. An S-Corp election would require paying herself a $35,000 salary, leaving only $10,000 in potential distribution savings. The $1,530 potential self-employment tax savings don't justify the added complexity and administrative costs. Payroll services and quarterly filings required for S-Corps can easily cost $ 1,000 or more annually, plus the time and effort spent.

Considerations for Choosing S-Corp for Tax Efficiency

S-Corporation elections typically benefit businesses when:

• You generate significant profits: Generally, businesses earning over $80,000 to $ 100,000 annually see meaningful savings that justify the additional complexity.
• You can support payroll infrastructure: You need systems to handle payroll taxes and quarterly filings accurately and efficiently.
• Your business income is stable: Fluctuating income makes it harder to maintain reasonable salary levels.

As attorney Bob Zeglarski, founder of Cutwater Law, PLLC, notes that an S-Corp election can make sense in specific situations: "I usually recommend an S-Corp to somebody who has a small business that won't have a lot of owners, be taking on investments down the road, and really be growing very much. An S-Corp could be a good fit for a small business that is planned to be operated as a family business because you get partnership tax treatment just like an LLC but also get the same liability protection as a C-Corporation" (TechInsurance, 2022).

Example: David's marketing agency generates $200,000 annually. By paying himself a $80,000 reasonable salary and taking $120,000 as distributions, he saves approximately $18,360 in self-employment taxes annually. Even after payroll costs, he nets over $17,000 in savings.Potential Tax Disadvantages of LLCs and S-Corps

Every tax strategy comes with trade-off. Understanding potential downsides helps you make informed decisions.

Making the right initial choice between an LLC or S-Corporation status can help prevent costly mistakes later.

Disadvantages of LLC Taxation

• Self-employment tax burden: Every dollar of LLC income gets hit with the 15.3% self-employment tax. For high-earning businesses, this creates significant tax consequences that S-Corporation elections can eliminate. Business owners must plan for these tax obligations each tax year.
• State-level complications: Some states impose LLC-specific taxes that don't apply to corporations. California's LLC fees can reach $11,790 annually for high-gross-receipt LLCs.

Disadvantages of S-Corp Taxation

• Self-employment tax burden: Every dollar of LLC income gets hit with the 15.3% self-employment tax. For high-earning businesses, this creates significant tax consequences that S-Corporation elections can eliminate. Business owners must plan for these tax obligations each tax year.
• State-level complications: Some states impose LLC-specific taxes that don't apply to corporations. California's LLC fees can reach $11,790 annually for high-gross-receipt LLCs.

Disadvantages of S-Corp Taxation

• Reasonable salary complexity: The IRS requires "reasonable" compensation for owner-employees but doesn't clearly define what constitutes "reasonable." Setting it too low triggers audit risk; too high negates tax benefits.
• Payroll administrative burden: Even single-owner S-Corps must run payroll, file quarterly reports, and maintain employment tax compliance. For most small businesses, this would mean hiring tax professionals. In addition to payroll requirements, S-Corps are required to appoint corporate officers and hold regular shareholder meetings as part of their compliance obligations. This includes recording meeting minutes and maintaining accurate business records.
• Shareholder limitations: Only eligible shareholders can own S-Corporation stock. Maximum 100 shareholders, all must be U.S. citizens, and only one class of stock is allowed. Compliance with federal tax rules is required to maintain S corporation status. These restrictions can limit growth opportunities.
• Rigid ownership rules: When new members contribute property to join the business, existing owners must retain at least 80% control, which can complicate business growth and ownership transfers.

FAQs

Can I switch from an LLC to an S-Corp or vice versa?

Yes, you can switch from an LLC to an S-Corp by filing Form 2553 with the IRS to elect S-Corp status. This process involves making an entity classification election with the IRS, which changes the tax status of your business. However, switching may involve specific tax implications, such as changes in how profits are distributed and taxed. You can also revoke the S-Corp election if needed, returning to default LLC taxation, but it requires filing the necessary paperwork and understanding the tax consequences.

Does forming an S-Corp provide more tax benefits than an LLC?

Not necessarily. Whether an S-Corp provides more tax benefits than an LLC depends on your business income and how you distribute profits. If you plan to pay yourself a significant salary and take large distributions, an S-Corp might help reduce self-employment taxes. However, LLCs offer greater flexibility in profit distribution and may be more beneficial in certain situations.

Are LLCs subject to any specific tax penalties or fees?

Some states impose additional taxes or fees on limited liability companies (LLCs). For example, California charges an annual franchise tax and a fee based on the LLC's income. It's essential to check state-specific requirements to avoid unexpected costs. This is something S-Corps might not be subject to in the same way, depending on the state.

Can an S-Corp have multiple owners?

Yes, an S-Corporation can have multiple shareholders. However, it is limited to a maximum of 100 shareholders, all of whom must be U.S. citizens or residents. The IRS restricts who can be an S-Corporation shareholder—generally, only individuals, certain trusts, and estates qualify. Corporation shareholders, such as other corporations or most limited liability companies (LLCs), are not eligible to be shareholders of an S corporation under IRS rules. Unlike an LLC, which has fewer restrictions on the number and type of owners, S-Corps have more specific rules governing ownership.

How does electing S-Corp status impact my state taxes?

Electing S-Corp status can have varying implications at the state level. Some states do not recognize S-Corporation tax status and treat it like a regular corporation, subjecting it to state corporate income taxes. Other states may offer tax breaks for S-Corps. Consult with a tax adviser and always check with your state's tax laws to understand the impact before making the election.

Get Expert Help with Your Tax Structure

Choosing between LLC and S-Corp taxation is too important to leave to guesswork. The wrong choice can cost you thousands annually in unnecessary taxes or administrative burdens that drain your focus from growing your business.

InCorp's business formation experts understand the nuances of tax elections and can help you evaluate your options while considering your unique circumstances and long-term goals. We file complex paperwork on your behalf, ensure accuracy and compliance with all requirements, and provide ongoing support to keep your business in good standing.

Don't let confusion about tax structures delay your success or cost you money every month. Get the expert guidance you need to make an informed decision for your specific situation.

Ready to explore your business structure options and understand potential tax implications? Contact InCorp today to speak with our experienced professionals and get the information you need to make the best choice for your business.

Share This Article: